The banking sector may not see a sharp acceleration in loan growth despite the large inflow of FCNR deposits, according to MB Mahesh, Analyst at Kotak Institutional Equities. He expects banks to use a sizeable portion of the new deposits to replace wholesale funding raised over the past year, rather than aggressively expand their loan books.Mahesh expects loan growth, currently running at around 17-18%, to moderate, while deposit growth could move closer to 15%. The immediate impact on margins is also likely to be limited, as banks may initially park a significant portion of the funds in their investment books or the VRR window before deploying them into loans.Mahesh sees some upside risk to bank earnings because the cost of raising these deposits has been relatively low. However, he does not expect a significant improvement in margins in the near term, with the benefit likely to become more visible towards the fourth quarter. He also remains positive on non-banking financial companies (NBFCs) if wholesale funding costs soften.The banking sector is set to see a significant inflow of deposits, with nearly ₹13 trillion expected to enter the system through the FCNR(B) deposit scheme.The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) data till August 15 showed that bank deposits had already risen by ₹4 trillion in the six weeks since June 30, highlighting the sharp increase in liquidity following the inflows.These are edited excerpts from the interview.Q: Do you see a surge in loan growth because banks have to lend this ₹13 trillion or ₹12 trillion?A: The way we are looking at this number is that we currently have a deposit gap, or a loans-to-deposit gap, of somewhere closer to about 400 basis points. To some extent, we don’t think banks will want to accelerate loan growth much faster than where it is today.When you look at the two sides, one is the opportunity to lend versus whether there is an intent to lend faster than where we are today. Our sense is that we are not going to see meaningful acceleration in credit growth from where we are. If anything, there could be a possible deceleration as well.The way we’re looking at these numbers is that much of these deposits will also be used to retire some of the wholesale deposits that were raised between October last year and March this year, when we saw a sudden acceleration in credit from the corporate side.Much of this credit growth was also funded by banks through wholesale deposits. To some extent, we are going to see a part of these deposits being used to retire the wholesale deposits that were raised. That’s how we’re looking at the breakup.Think of it this way: current loan growth of somewhere close to 17-18% is probably heading lower than where it is. The deposit growth, which was running at about 12-13%, moves closer to that 15% kind of a mark, we address both sides of the balance sheet through the FCNR window out here.Q: Yes, they will retire bulk deposits, but there is extra money that has come in by way of foreign deposits. Even when deposit growth fell, one big reason was that FIIs pulled out actual money. Money went out of the system, and now some of that has come in. My sense is there is going to be more money. Even if I retire the bulk deposit, that money has to be lent somewhere. It stays as money in the system. Don’t you think bank credit will still be high?A: You can break that argument into two parts. I have to raise, at any given point in time, a certain amount of deposits either through the CASA side, retail term deposits or wholesale term deposits over the next nine to 12 months.Total deposits that have come through the FCNR channel are approximately 5%, and in any given year, we are looking at somewhere close to 12-15% deposit growth.A third of those deposits, which usually come from the wholesale side, I don’t think will be accessed by the banking system for close to the next six to nine months.The way you look at it is that the retail term deposit engine continues where it is. CASA deposits continue to grow as they are. You probably put a little more focus on CASA deposits over the next six to nine months, and you don’t target wholesale deposits, at least in the interim period.If these excess deposits come in, banks have the option of putting them into the investment book or the loan portfolio. Banks will be a bit more measured, rather than immediately accelerating credit growth. I don’t think that is likely to happen, at least initially.Q: Will the quality of loans given change? Because the ALM is changing. The deposits that are coming in are for three to five years, and I understand that more of them are five-year deposits. That’s stable money. So, will we see the nature of loans changing, say, from personal loans to auto loans or housing loans, or corporate loans, simply because banks now have slightly longer-term money?A: If you look at that argument and at how the maturity profile of deposits has moved, you can look at the RBI numbers on this. Over the last five to six years, the maturity profile of deposits itself has been coming down.To some extent, the ALMs of Indian banks have become shorter, with the maturity profile coming down from where it was four or five years ago.I don’t think you will change the asset mix simply because you have access to a longer-tenor deposit. It just corrects some of the changes that have happened so far.Q: What about margins? Will they improve for the rest of the year?A: You have to look at the argument from two sides. One, you’ve had a very big source of deposits coming in within a month. The probability that institutions will be able to deploy such a large amount of assets on the loan side is low.So, over the next 30 to 45 days, a large part of it will be sitting in the investment portfolio, or it will be in the VRR window.As loan demand starts to move higher, banks can start deploying those deposits as well. So, the margin impact will be lower in quarter two. It will probably be a little lower in quarter three, and then it starts improving as we get into quarter four.Q: Let me ask it directly, because I heard this from another analyst. Will you be reworking earnings growth at all? Even if margins don’t improve, if loan growth improves or whatever, NII is better, are your EPS or earnings forecasts likely to shift higher? Is there an upside risk?A: That is true. The amount of deposits that have come in is a bit higher. The cost of originating these deposits has been fairly low. So, even if you were to deploy it in a low-yielding investment like a G-Sec on the other side, it adds to the NII number.So, directionally, you should see earnings being revised a bit higher than where they are today. But, from a quantitative standpoint, it’s not going to be a meaningfully high number.We will have to see the data as it comes in and assess how much of a revision will be required.Q: Would you worry that two years or one year down the line, we may see slightly higher bad loans because people are in a hurry to lend this money? This is a worry that even a central banker expressed to me. To quote his sentence: until now, I was giving loans to people with a CIBIL score of 750; will I start lowering it to 700 because there is money sitting?A: The primary argument behind that hypothesis is that loan growth will probably accelerate. We will have to wait and see whether that is the behaviour lenders are exhibiting.From what we have seen, banks, at least since the post-COVID period, have generally been fairly tight in terms of the quality of underwriting they have maintained.Even if you look at the 2024-25 and 2025-26 periods, when we had issues with the unsecured loan portfolio, it has not resulted in meaningfully higher delinquencies for the banking system.So, we don’t want to jump a few steps ahead of where we are today. We need to first see loan growth being faster than expected and look at the composition of those assets before making these assumptions.To some extent, we are of the opinion that growth is probably going to be a bit lower, and not higher. That is different from the stance you are taking.Q: This is a more general question to all the analysts who come on the channel. You have a bias towards private sector banks or small finance banks. I don’t see enough public sector banks in your list. You have State Bank of India (SBI) in your list, and SBI does figure in many people’s lists, but you don’t go below the line. Any reason? Because the best performers over the last two or three years have been public sector banks. Why are they still not widely recommended?A: I don’t think that statement is entirely true. We’ve had buys in other PSU banks as well.But, to be fair, the challenge usually comes from how we build long-term confidence in many of these institutions. Having said that, if you look at the underwriting that many of the PSU banks have demonstrated over the last five years or so, it’s fair to assume that they have done their part to show that their underwriting is also getting closer to, or at par with, where the frontline private banks are.But it takes time. It will take a few more cycles for us to establish that confidence, given what we saw at these institutions in the previous decade.For full interview, watch the accompanying video
Source link
Banks unlikely to accelerate loan growth despite FCNR deposit surge: Kotak Institutional Equities
Date:

