A US federal court is set to decide whether an investment bank can fire a junior employee who sought guaranteed sleep hours as a medical accommodation, in a case that has reignited debate over Wall Street’s punishing work culture, according to a report by the Financial Post.
Kathryn Shiber, a former analyst at Centerview Partnershas sued the elite New York-based advisory boutique for disability discrimination under federal and state law after she was terminated in 2020. Shortly after she joined the firm, Centerview granted her a guaranteed nine-hour nightly sleep window to manage a diagnosed mood and anxiety disorder. In return, she agreed to remain available to work at all other times, seven days a week.
Less than three weeks after the arrangement was implemented, Shiber was dismissed during a video call. She alleges the firm’s chief operating officer criticised her for applying for an investment banking role despite her need for consistent rest. The jury trial in federal court in New York is scheduled to begin next week.
In an earlier ruling allowing the case to proceed, US District Judge Edgardo Ramos said there was a “genuine dispute” over whether round-the-clock availability and long, unpredictable hours were essential functions of the analyst role, the report said.
The lawsuit comes against the backdrop of long-running concerns over working conditions in investment banking. In 2021, first-year analysts at Goldman Sachs circulated a presentation detailing gruelling hours and sleep deprivation during the pandemic, prompting several firms to introduce measures such as capped hours and protected weekend time off.
Shiber is seeking back pay, future lost earnings over the next decade and damages for emotional distress, potentially amounting to millions of dollars. She argues her dismissal permanently derailed her investment banking career.
Centerview has maintained that junior bankers across Wall Street are expected to work long and often unpredictable hours. In court filings, the firm said the nine-hour sleep window was intended as a short-term solution and that no reasonable accommodation would allow Shiber to perform the role if she required eight to nine hours of consistent nightly sleep.
A key issue at trial is likely to be whether overnight availability is truly essential to the job or simply an entrenched industry norm. Legal experts cited in the report noted that disability discrimination claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act rarely make it to a jury trial.
Shiber, a graduate of Dartmouth Collegehad been working on a high-profile mandate to defend Duke Energy from a potential proxy contest led by activist hedge fund Elliott Management. Emails and testimony cited in court filings indicate the firm later believed her nightly absence affected team cohesion and her professional development.
Founded in 2006, Centerview generates more than $2 billion in annual revenue despite having fewer employees than rivals such as Moelis & Co and Lazard.
The outcome of the trial could have significant implications for how Wall Street firms balance demanding client-driven schedules with disability accommodation requirements under US law, the report said.

