India’s dramatic 30-run defeat to South Africa at Eden Gardens has sparked widespread criticism from former cricketers, who questioned the team’s selection calls and tactical clarity.The hosts crumbled while chasing just 124, prompting concerns over India’s declining strength on turning tracks. Former pacer Venkatesh Prasad was particularly blunt, saying the loss exposed deeper issues in India’s red-ball planning.“While we have been excellent in white-ball cricket, we can’t call ourselves a top Test side with such planning. Selections without clarity and over-tactical thinking are backfiring. Poor results over a year in Tests, barring a drawn series in England,” Prasad posted on X.
A back-pedalling Bavuma followed a swirling ball and took a smart catch to remove Axar Patel that effectively sealed their victory in front of 40,000-odd fans at Eden Gardens.Off-spinner Simon Harmer’s haul of eight wickets earned him the player-of-the-match award but Bavuma’s heroic unbeaten 55 dragged his team back into the contest.Bavuma did not disagree when asked if he felt South Africa beat India in their own game on a pitch like that.”Yeah, probably true,” he told reporters after South Africa went 1-0 up in the two-test series.
“We’ve come here knowing that the wickets are going to be spinner-friendly, similar to what we got in this game. So it didn’t come as a surprise.”Despite having so little to defend, Bavuma said he never stopped trusting his bowlers.”It’s not every day you go and score 125, and you feel that’s a winning score.”But we had to believe. We knew it was tough. We saw with our own innings, with the bat.”India were one batsman short as skipper Shubman Gill retired hurt in the first innings and did not bat in the second.India coach Gautam Gambhir defended the pitch, while vice-captain Rishabh Pant said they should have been able to pull off the chase even in Gill’s absence.”Definitely there was help in the wicket,” Pant said.”A (target) of 120 can be tricky on these kinds of surfaces, but at the same time, as a team we should be able to soak in the pressure.”(With Reuters inputs)

