Pakistan has been placed on and off the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) grey list since 2008 for failing to dismantle terror-financing networks. Its efforts have been episodic and often cosmetic, designed more for placating global pressure than instituting genuine reform. Ceasefires, in this context, become convenient instruments—temporary palliatives in place of structural accountability.
Trusting Pakistan on Peace: A Difficult PropositionThe notion of achieving lasting peace with Pakistan has long been mired in scepticism, given its track record of backing terror activities against India. The repeated cycles of ceasefires and promises of peace often end in renewed provocations, leading one to ask: how can India trust that Pakistan will truly cease its hostilities?
For decades, Pakistan has used peace talks as a political tool, often buying time to re-arm and reorganise its proxy terror networks. Past experiences have shown that whenever Pakistan has agreed to ceasefire arrangements, it has strategically used the interval to reinforce its terror infrastructure rather than dismantling it. Whether it was in Kargil or in more recent border skirmishes, the enduring pattern has been the same. These recurring betrayals undermine any trust in Pakistan’s commitment to long-term peace.
More troubling is the role of Pakistan’s military establishment, which exercises near-total control over the state’s foreign policy and strategic decisions. As a result, diplomatic overtures made by civilian leadership are often undermined by entrenched military interests. For India, this means that peace negotiations with Pakistan are not just with a government, but with an institution that has made cross-border terrorism an integral part of its strategy. Until the balance of power within Pakistan shifts away from its military’s terror leanings, any peace deal will remain precarious at best.
Strategic Indulgence at the Cost of Integrity
In 2023, investigative reporting by The Intercept uncovered covert arms transactions routed through Pakistan to support US military operations in Ukraine—occurring in parallel with renewed IMF disbursements. A year earlier, in 2022, the US was reportedly entangled in diplomatic efforts that contributed to the ousting of Pakistan’s elected Prime Minister, largely due to his neutral stance on the Russia-Ukraine conflict. These episodes raise a persistent and uncomfortable truth — that for all its rhetoric on democracy and a rules-based order, Washington’s strategic imperatives often override institutional integrity and democratic legitimacy within the global governance framework it claims to defend.
Indeed, the American footprint in South Asia has never stemmed from historical affinity—it is a product of cold, calculated interest. Whether it was arming Pakistan during the Cold War, enabling the rise of jihadist networks in the 1980s, or supporting military regimes to counter Soviet and now Chinese influence, the pattern is consistent. The US has repeatedly channelled support—financial, military, and diplomatic—to actors who destabilise the region, so long as they remain useful to American strategic calculus. It is a policy of instrumentalism disguised as alliance-building, whose cost is borne most heavily by those subjected to asymmetric violence and political duplicity.
Despite repeated provocations from Pakistani military and terror intrusions, India has thus far responded with calibrated restraint, limiting its actions to surgically targeting terror-linked sites and military enablers. Yet such restraint must not be misread as permanent pliancy. Every provocation chips away at the space for diplomacy, and the threshold for escalation narrows with each unpunished transgression.
The Strategic Competition: US and China in the Race to Control Pakistan
The US-Pakistan relationship has always been transactional, guided by geopolitical calculations rather than any genuine desire for peace in the region. From supporting Pakistan during the Cold War to enabling its military capabilities in the fight against the Soviet Union, the US has long seen Pakistan as a strategic asset. However, this relationship is fraught with contradictions: while the US claims to be fighting terrorism, it continues to fund and maintain close ties with a state that harbours terror groups targeting India. How, then, can the US be trusted to mediate peace when its support for Pakistan continues, despite clear evidence of Islamabad’s harbouring of terror networks?
Similarly, China’s increasing influence in Pakistan through the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) adds another layer of complexity. In its race to expand its strategic footprint in South Asia and the Indian Ocean, China has invested heavily in Pakistan’s infrastructure, military capabilities, and economy. For Beijing, its relationship with Islamabad is part of a broader strategy to counterbalance India’s growing regional influence. As a result, China has become a powerful patron of Pakistan, shielding it from international pressure and offering it resources in return for strategic access.
The dynamics of the US-China competition, coupled with Pakistan’s strategic value to both powers, render the idea of neutral mediators in the region increasingly difficult to realise. Instead, the pursuit of peace is at risk of being compromised by the broader global chess game between Washington and Beijing.
The Real Test of Peace
The only ceasefire that matters to India is one that ends terrorism—not one that merely postpones it. So, the real question is — what will compel Pakistan to abandon its terror-industrial complex and behave as a responsible member of the international community? This is not an issue of capability, but of consequence. So long as it receives indulgence—via funding, diplomatic cover, or geopolitical partnership—the incentives to transform remain low.
—The author, Dr. Srinath Sridharan ( @ssmumbai), is a Corporate advisor & Independent Director on Corporate Boards. The views expressed are personal.
Read his previous articles here

